As the deadline for the transition of Grade Nine learners approaches, a heated debate has erupted among education stakeholders regarding the hosting of these students. The upcoming transition, part of Kenya’s competency-based curriculum (CBC) implementation, has highlighted significant differences in opinion among educators, parents, and government officials.
The primary contention revolves around whether Grade Nine learners should be hosted in primary or secondary school facilities. Proponents of hosting them in primary schools argue that these institutions are better equipped to handle the developmental needs of younger adolescents. They emphasize the familiar environment and continuity for learners who have spent their foundational years in these schools.
On the other hand, those advocating for secondary schools as the appropriate hosts for Grade Nine learners point out the advanced facilities and resources available at these institutions. They argue that secondary schools can better support the academic rigor and extracurricular activities required at this education level.
Primary School Advocates: Teachers and administrators from primary schools have voiced their readiness to accommodate Grade Nine learners. Jane Wambui, a headteacher in Nairobi, stated, “Our primary schools have been the nurturing ground for these students. Transitioning them here for Grade Nine will ensure they remain in a familiar and supportive environment.”
Secondary School Supporters: Conversely, secondary school stakeholders argue that the infrastructure and resources at their disposal make them better suited for the task. Peter Ochieng, a principal at a prominent secondary school, noted, “We have the laboratories, libraries, and extracurricular programs that will enrich the educational experience for Grade Nine learners. They will also benefit from early exposure to the secondary school environment.”
Parents are caught in the middle of this debate, with opinions divided. Some parents support the idea of their children staying in primary schools for an additional year, citing emotional and psychological comfort. Others believe that moving to secondary schools will provide their children with better preparation for future academic challenges.
Mary Mwikali, a concerned parent, shared her perspective, “I want my child to have the best possible education. If that means staying in primary school for another year, so be it. But if secondary schools can offer more, then we should consider that option.”
The Ministry of Education has been relatively silent on the matter, leading to increased speculation and anxiety among stakeholders. A recent statement from the ministry promised a definitive decision soon, emphasizing that the well-being and academic success of the students are the top priorities.
Education Cabinet Secretary Ezekiel Machogu said, “We understand the concerns from all parties involved. Our goal is to ensure a smooth transition that benefits the learners the most. We are considering all viewpoints and will make an informed decision shortly.”
