England ended a challenging year on a high note with a commanding 59-14 victory over Japan in the Autumn Nations Series, scoring nine tries in the process. While the scoreline provided a much-needed confidence boost, the match underscored that England performs best against less experienced opposition. This win marked only their fifth in twelve Tests this year, with other victories coming against Italy, Wales, and Japan earlier in the season.
From the outset, England dominated their opponents, scoring more tries in this match than in their previous three games combined. Hookers Jamie George and Luke Cowan-Dickie each crossed the line twice, leading the charge. Henry Slade’s creative influence in midfield stood out, while the team’s overall cohesion showcased their ability to capitalize on Japan’s inexperience. However, the ease of the victory did little to answer questions about England’s readiness for stronger opponents, with upcoming fixtures against Ireland and France likely to provide a more accurate measure.
The match began with England surging ahead, notching three tries within the first 23 minutes. Despite a disallowed try from Tommy Freeman due to a minor knock-on, England’s dominance was clear. Their safety-first selection policy, however, raised eyebrows, particularly regarding the inclusion of Tom Curry, who had recently returned from a concussion. While the decision ensured England fielded a strong team, it also highlighted ongoing concerns about player welfare.
Jamie George’s two tries from driven mauls typified England’s effective forward play. Additionally, the build-up to Ollie Sleightholme’s try just before halftime demonstrated England’s skill in open play, with sharp passing from George Furbank and Slade creating space. Sleightholme, who matched his father Jon’s England try tally in just two weeks, has shown a promising knack for finishing, drawing comparisons to legendary winger Rory Underwood.
Japan, missing key players such as suspended lock Warner Dearns, struggled to compete. However, they managed moments of brilliance, including a spectacular long-range try from captain Naoto Saito after a break by Dylan Riley. Despite this highlight, Japan’s lack of quick ball and consistent pressure left them overwhelmed by halftime, with England leading 35-7.
The second half allowed England to introduce younger players, such as Sale’s 20-year-old prop Asher Opoku-Fordjour, who made a solid impression in his 25-minute cameo. England’s backs continued to showcase moments of flair, exemplified by Freeman’s audacious behind-the-back flick that set up Furbank’s try. The introduction of Fin Smith at fly-half and Marcus Smith’s shift to full-back hinted at tactical experimentation, though the team remained in control rather than shifting into high gear.
Luke Cowan-Dickie’s rampaging performance delivered two second-half tries, emphasizing England’s dominance in close quarters. Japan responded with a powerful finish by Kazuki Himeno, but it was one of their few bright spots in an otherwise lopsided contest. Late tries from Tom Roebuck and Cowan-Dickie capped off England’s performance, highlighting the bench’s impact in the final stages.
Despite the comprehensive victory, the result did little to shift the narrative surrounding England’s season. The team’s reliance on established players and cautious game plans reflects a focus on avoiding losses rather than bold experimentation. With the Six Nations approaching, head coach Steve Borthwick has limited time to refine the team’s approach ahead of tougher challenges.
In Dublin, England will face an Ireland side brimming with confidence, followed by a clash with France, one of the world’s top teams. These matches will provide a far sterner test of England’s capabilities and offer a clearer indication of their progress. For now, this emphatic win over Japan serves as a reminder of England’s potential when facing weaker opposition, but the true test lies ahead.
