England’s recent rugby struggles have ignited questions about head coach Steve Borthwick’s gameplan, especially after a stinging defeat to Australia. This loss has intensified scrutiny on England’s inability to finish big games, despite scoring five tries and accumulating 37 points a tally that should have ensured victory. This isn’t the first time England has scored high but still lost; just last March, they scored 31 points in Lyon and still couldn’t win against France. This ongoing trend hints at a recurring issue with defensive consistency, which is costly for a team in need of reliable resilience.
In addition to 35 missed tackles in their latest match, England’s performance problems seem multifaceted. The efficiency of their bench, struggles in the scrum, repeated injuries, and questions around leadership in critical moments all add to the mix. Yet, Borthwick’s steadfast belief in his strategy continues, even as it fails to deliver consistent wins. With world champions South Africa as their next opponent, England now faces an uphill battle, and the spotlight on Borthwick’s system grows even brighter.
In the past, England has thrived under pressure, using adversity to fuel successful runs. But recent performances have displayed a split personality. They seem more precise in execution when they simplify their approach, but as they introduce more complexity, their control slips. Despite this, they continue to adhere to a method that allows skillful opponents to exploit them. It’s worth considering whether England’s repeated losses stem from a lack of commitment to the system or if, on a deeper level, the players themselves lack full confidence in its effectiveness.
The team’s recent performances suggest an internal disconnect that has led to costly missteps. For example, with six minutes left in the game and England ahead 30-28, George Ford made a play that backfired, resulting in a turnover that led to a decisive try from Australia’s Andrew Kellaway. This kind of decision-making is concerning, and Borthwick has rightly expressed frustration. He’s questioned the players’ judgment under pressure, but the errors may stem from a deeper lack of alignment between the coaching staff’s vision and the players’ execution.
Compounding these issues is the question of player selection. Ford’s placement at fly-half over Marcus Smith, a talented playmaker who was instead positioned at fullback, seems to have had a destabilizing effect. Ford’s experience was intended to bring calm and stability, yet it has not translated into effective leadership on the pitch. This is the second game in a row where England’s approach has unraveled, leaving Borthwick and the team to reflect on their decisions.
Amid these setbacks, concerns about morale loom. Six losses in their last eight Tests have dented England’s confidence, and the dressing room’s atmosphere could be at risk. Veteran players, including Jamie George, might benefit from rest to avoid further strain. Meanwhile, key players like Tom Curry need time to recover fully from injury, especially given his recent concussions. The midfield combination still feels out of balance, and Joe Marler’s decision to decline a request to play against South Africa raises questions about squad cohesion. The looming presence of South Africa’s powerful “Bomb Squad” forwards only heightens the challenges England will face this week.
Beyond this immediate test, England’s upcoming fixtures reveal a daunting path. A match against Japan might offer some reprieve, but the Six Nations opener in Dublin followed by a game against France could prove decisive. If England continues to struggle, they could end up with nine losses in their last twelve games, potentially facing a disappointing Six Nations finish. The Rugby Football Union is under pressure too, as its financial stability depends on a successful men’s team.
Australia’s win not only highlighted England’s struggles but also underscored how well-prepared they were for England’s defense. They demonstrated the value of tactical creativity, using speed and precision to dismantle England’s blitz defense. Australia’s performance, led by standout players like Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii, Len Ikitau, and the 20-year-old Max Jorgensen, showcased a style of rugby that England struggled to contain. This recent victory raises expectations for next summer’s British & Irish Lions tour to Australia, where fewer English players may feature if these struggles continue.
In the end, England’s talent and commitment are evident, but the team has yet to find cohesive rhythm. They’re like an orchestra where all the musicians are skilled, yet they’re still struggling to play in harmony.
