Manchester United’s 3-3 draw against FC Porto in the Europa League was another rollercoaster performance that showcased both the best and worst of the Red Devils. Harry Maguire emerged as the unlikely hero, rescuing his team from a potential embarrassment with a late equalizer. This match, while highlighting individual moments of brilliance, also revealed deeper issues that continue to plague Erik ten Hag’s side, leaving the Dutch manager under mounting pressure. With United now four games without a win, questions about tactical choices, defensive frailties, and midfield cohesion remain unanswered.
The match started promisingly for United. Marcus Rashford, in fine form, opened the scoring just seven minutes into the game. His goal was a showcase of his individual brilliance, cutting through Porto’s defense with ease before unleashing a shot that beat Diogo Costa, Porto’s goalkeeper. Although Costa might have done better to stop the goal, the speed and precision of Rashford’s play were undeniably impressive. Rashford didn’t stop there, as he continued to torment the Porto backline with his pace and intelligence. Just minutes later, he set up United’s second goal, threading a perfectly-timed pass to Rasmus Hojlund, who finished confidently. Costa, once again, was found wanting in goal.
At this point, it seemed as if United were cruising to victory. Rashford’s display was a reminder of the talent he possesses, even if such performances have been inconsistent in recent months. However, the joy was short-lived. Porto, to their credit, didn’t back down. The momentum began to shift when United’s goalkeeper, Andre Onana, made a decent save, only for the ball to land perfectly for Porto’s Brazilian forward, Pepe, who slotted it home to halve the deficit. Porto’s belief grew from there, and just seven minutes later, Samu Omorodion out-jumped Matthijs de Ligt to head in the equalizer.
United’s defense, which has been a point of concern throughout the season, was exposed once again. The center-back pairing of De Ligt and Lisandro Martinez struggled to deal with Porto’s physicality and movement, particularly in the case of Samu, who consistently outmuscled and out-positioned De Ligt. It was a sobering reminder of the defensive vulnerabilities that have haunted United this campaign, even with a big-money signing like De Ligt in the heart of the defense.
The second half saw Porto continue to build on their comeback, and within five minutes of the restart, they took the lead. Pepe, who had been a thorn in United’s side, turned provider this time, cutting the ball back for Samu to score his second of the night. Once again, De Ligt was caught out of position, failing to track Samu’s run. It was an all-too-familiar story for United fans, as the team’s defensive disorganization was laid bare.
The situation took another turn for the worse when Bruno Fernandes, United’s captain and creative spark, was sent off in the 81st minute. His red card, a result of a reckless high boot, left United with 10 men and seemingly on the brink of defeat. It was a moment that encapsulated Fernandes’ season so far – flashes of brilliance marred by moments of frustration and poor decision-making. His dismissal only compounded the pressure on Ten Hag, who has been grappling with a team that can show brilliance but often implodes under pressure.
However, just when it seemed like all hope was lost, Harry Maguire stepped up. Having come off the bench earlier in the match, the much-maligned center-back rose highest to meet Christian Eriksen’s corner in the 87th minute, heading the ball past Costa to salvage a point for United. It was a moment of redemption for Maguire, who has faced intense criticism over the past year for his performances. While his goal may have saved United from defeat, it doesn’t mask the larger issues within the squad.
Looking at United’s overall performance, there were a few standouts. Rashford’s first-half display was exceptional, showcasing his ability to change a game with his pace, dribbling, and vision. Hojlund also impressed, taking his goal well and showing glimpses of why United invested in him as a long-term striking option. Christian Eriksen, though not always in the spotlight, was a steadying presence in midfield, contributing to both of United’s early goals and delivering the corner that led to Maguire’s equalizer.
On the defensive side, however, the concerns were glaring. De Ligt, in particular, struggled throughout the match, losing his duels with Samu on both of Porto’s headed goals. His positioning and awareness were questionable, and his partnership with Martinez never looked comfortable. Martinez himself had a mixed night, making an important block to deny Samu in the second half but also being caught out on several occasions.
In midfield, Casemiro had another poor outing. The Brazilian, who was once a rock-solid presence in front of the defense, seemed off the pace, often leaving United’s backline exposed. His inability to read the game and cover spaces was a major reason why Porto found so much joy going forward. In contrast, Eriksen offered more in terms of creativity and control, but he couldn’t compensate for Casemiro’s lack of defensive awareness.
United’s substitutions had varying levels of impact. Alejandro Garnacho, brought on for Rashford at half-time, was lively and direct but lacked the cutting edge in front of goal, taking eight shots but failing to convert. Antony, who replaced Amad Diallo, also struggled to make a significant impact, with his best contributions coming from two long-range efforts that didn’t trouble the goalkeeper. Joshua Zirkzee, another substitute, barely saw the ball during his time on the pitch.
Ten Hag’s tactical approach will undoubtedly come under scrutiny following this game. United started brightly but seemed to lose control of the match as soon as Porto began to assert themselves. The midfield was overrun too easily, and the defense was vulnerable to Porto’s aerial threat and counter-attacks. Ten Hag has built a reputation as a tactical innovator, but his inability to address United’s recurring defensive issues is becoming a major concern. The lack of cohesion and discipline in his side is evident, and with the team now winless in four games, the pressure on him is mounting.
The red card for Fernandes further complicates matters for Ten Hag. The Portuguese midfielder is a key figure for United, both as a captain and a playmaker, but his temperament has come into question this season. His dismissal means he will miss future Europa League matches, adding to United’s growing list of problems.
Despite the late equalizer, this draw feels more like two points dropped rather than one gained. United had the game in their hands after Rashford’s and Hojlund’s early goals, but their inability to defend leads and manage games continues to cost them. While Maguire’s late heroics may have salvaged a point, the underlying issues within the squad remain unresolved.
In conclusion, this 3-3 draw against Porto was a microcosm of Manchester United’s season so far – moments of individual brilliance overshadowed by defensive frailties, poor game management, and a lack of cohesion. Erik ten Hag has a lot of work to do if he is to turn things around. The clock is ticking, and with each passing game, the pressure on him to find solutions grows. For now, Maguire’s goal might have spared United from defeat, but it doesn’t change the fact that this team has serious problems that need to be addressed, and fast.
