When choosing the perfect “your lips but better” lipstick shade, the process doesn’t need to be as complicated as some of the quirky beauty hacks suggest. Forget about matching your lipstick to your nipples or the color of your fingertip. The key to finding a flattering nude or natural lip shade lies in selecting a semi-transparent formula that enhances your natural lip color, rather than masking it entirely.
The ideal “your lips but better” lipsticks are those that deepen the natural tone of your lips while still allowing the natural lip color to shine through. These shades typically offer a sheer veil of color, providing a subtle enhancement without being too bold. One of the most iconic examples of this is Clinique’s Black Honey, which has become a cult favorite over the years. This shade strikes the perfect balance between nude and bold, offering a deep, berry-like hue that looks effortlessly chic in both professional and casual settings. Clinique offers Black Honey in a variety of formulas, including a sheer lip and cheek oil and the less shiny Almost Lipstick, both of which provide a sophisticated, understated look.
If you’re looking for a more affordable alternative, e.l.f.’s Sheer Slick Black Cherry Lipstick is a great option. While it’s clearly inspired by Clinique’s Black Honey, it leans slightly pinker and less rich in tone. However, it still provides a sheer and flattering finish at a fraction of the price. For those who prefer a more pink-toned natural look, Ilia’s Balmy Gloss Tinted Lip Oil in Linger is a solid choice. This formula is lightweight and gives lips a subtle wash of color, making it an easy-to-wear option for everyday use.
Another standout product in this category is Summer Fridays’ Lip Butter Balm in Brown Sugar. This balm is a moisturizing treat for the lips, offering a clear, syrupy burgundy gloss that enhances the natural skin tone without overwhelming it. The balm has a pleasant, sweet flavor that makes it even more enjoyable to apply throughout the day. It’s a great option for those who prefer a more hydrating, glossy finish that still provides a touch of color.
It’s important to distinguish between these sheer, enhancing formulas and “color adaptive” lipsticks. Color adaptive products, which react to your skin’s pH to create a personalized shade, often result in an unnatural, fuchsia-pink hue that can be off-putting. These types of lipsticks rarely deliver the subtle, natural effect that many are seeking when choosing a “your lips but better” shade.
For those who want an even lighter touch of color, lip oils are an excellent option. These products provide a glossy, non-sticky finish with just a hint of pigment, perfect for those who want to enhance their lips without committing to a full lipstick. Clarins Comfort Lip Oil in Chocolate and Dior Addict Lip Glow Oil in Mahogany are two universally flattering lip oils that offer a natural-looking tint and a glossy finish, making them great choices for anyone looking for a more understated, effortless look.
In summary, when selecting the perfect “your lips but better” lipstick, focus on formulas that offer a sheer, semi-transparent finish. Look for shades that enhance your natural lip color, rather than mask it, and choose products that are versatile enough to wear in any setting. Whether you prefer a balm, gloss, or lipstick, the key is to find a product that feels comfortable and enhances your natural beauty.
