Justice Lilian Mutende, chairperson of the National Community Service Orders Committee (NCSOC), has proposed a significant shift in the approach to handling petty offenders. Her proposal calls for the release of minor offenders and the adoption of non-custodial measures as a solution to the mounting prison population crisis.
Justice Mutende, a High Court judge, recently discussed her recommendations during an interview on Citizen TV’s Daybreak program. She highlighted the critical issue of prison congestion, which has been exacerbated by outdated infrastructure and a growing inmate population. The correctional facilities in Kenya, some of which date back to the colonial era, have long struggled to keep pace with the demands of a rapidly increasing population.
“The current prison facilities were built a long time ago, some even during the colonial period. Despite renovations and the addition of new facilities, they remain inadequate due to the rising population,” Justice Mutende explained. Her solution to this problem is to focus on reforming the judicial system to incorporate alternative punishments for minor crimes.
Justice Mutende advocates for a restorative justice approach, where non-custodial sentences and community service are used as alternatives to imprisonment for petty offenses. She argues that only “hardcore criminals” should be held in prisons, while minor offenders should be subjected to community service, rehabilitation, and reconciliation with victims. This approach, she believes, would not only ease the burden on the prison system but also promote a more effective form of justice for less severe crimes.
This proposal is timely and aligns with recent statements from President William Ruto, who has also been vocal about the need for alternative dispute resolution methods to combat prison overcrowding. In April of the previous year, President Ruto highlighted that over 10,000 prisoners were serving sentences of less than three years, and a significant portion of the prison population—41 percent—was awaiting trial for bailable offenses. The President has supported the idea of exploring alternative measures to reduce the prison population, emphasizing the urgent need for reform.
The situation in Kenyan prisons is indeed dire. According to the newly-appointed Prisons Commissioner General Patrick Aranduh, the current prison population stands at approximately 62,000 inmates, far exceeding the designed capacity of 30,000. This severe overcrowding has led to deteriorating conditions within the facilities, affecting both inmates and staff.
Justice Mutende’s proposal offers a practical and compassionate solution to this issue. By shifting the focus from incarceration to community service and rehabilitation for petty offenders, the prison system can be alleviated, allowing for more effective management of the inmate population. This approach not only addresses the immediate problem of overcrowding but also supports broader criminal justice reform, aimed at creating a more equitable and effective system.
Community service orders, as suggested by Justice Mutende, would require petty offenders to contribute to the community in meaningful ways, fostering a sense of responsibility and accountability. This method aligns with global trends towards restorative justice, which emphasize repairing harm and reintegrating offenders into society.
The successful implementation of Justice Mutende’s proposal would require collaboration between the judiciary, the executive, and correctional institutions. It would also necessitate the development of a robust framework to ensure that community service and other non-custodial sentences are effectively monitored and enforced.
In conclusion, Justice Mutende’s call for the release of petty offenders and the adoption of non-custodial measures represents a significant step towards addressing the overcrowding crisis in Kenyan prisons. By embracing restorative justice and focusing on rehabilitation, Kenya can work towards a more humane and effective criminal justice system, alleviating the pressures on its correctional facilities and ultimately benefiting society as a whole.
