Kenn Okaka: Matano is Wrong; Criticizing Fellow Coaches is Unprofessional

Tusker FC head coach Robert Matano is completely off the mark in his harsh criticism of other Kenyan football tacticians. Labeling his peers as failures is not only unprofessional but also an unsportsmanlike display that tarnishes the spirit of football camaraderie. Matano needs to be reminded that demeaning fellow coaches is a misguided approach and reflects poorly on his professionalism.

Matano’s recent outburst targeted the Football Kenya Federation (FKF) for its alleged repeated appointment of underperforming coaches to lead the Harambee Stars. He questioned the competence of these coaches, including current Harambee Stars head coach Engin Firat, Kariobangi Sharks tactician William Muluya, and Stars’ assistant coach Ken Odhiambo. Matano labeled them as “absolute failures” with “nothing to show,” a statement that is not only baseless but also unfair.

It is worth noting that Matano himself is a coach in the FKF Premier League and has faced criticism for his coaching methods in the past. During those times, he received support and image protection from his peers and the Federation. His current stance, therefore, appears hypocritical and disrespectful to the same community that stood by him.

Comparing credentials and achievements, Firat’s extensive experience with national teams evidently surpasses Matano’s. Firat’s tactical acumen and strong interpersonal relationships with players demonstrate his competence and effectiveness as a coach. Additionally, the young and innovative coaches Muluya and Odhiambo have shown significant advancement in modern football tactics and training, contributing positively to their teams and the league.

Kariobangi Sharks, under Muluya, are currently recognized for playing some of the best football in the FKF Premier League. In contrast, Matano’s Tusker FC, while competitive, does not exhibit the same level of tactical innovation or performance consistency.

It is essential for senior coaches like Matano to foster an environment of mutual respect and encouragement. Criticizing and demeaning fellow coaches only serves to create division and negativity within the football community. Instead, experienced coaches should mentor and support younger and less experienced colleagues, promoting growth and unity within the sport.

In conclusion, Robert Matano’s disparaging comments about his fellow coaches are uncalled for and detrimental to the Kenyan football fraternity. Constructive criticism and professional conduct are vital for the development of the sport. It is high time that Matano reflects on his actions and chooses to uplift rather than tear down his peers.