The recent appointment of John Mbadi as the Cabinet Secretary (CS) for the National Treasury has stirred significant changes in Kenya’s fiscal landscape, particularly in how the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) is managed. One of the key figures caught in this transition is Anthony Mwaura, the current chairman of the KRA, whose assertive leadership style has sparked controversy and scrutiny.
Mwaura’s leadership has been characterized by a blurring of the lines between the board’s oversight responsibilities and the executive functions traditionally reserved for the Commissioner General. His actions have led to tension within the organization, as he has taken on roles typically associated with the Commissioner General, who is the chief executive officer (CEO) of KRA. This overlap has raised concerns about governance and the proper functioning of the institution.
Governance Challenges Under Mwaura
Mwaura’s approach has not gone unnoticed, with the new Treasury CS, John Mbadi, emphasizing the need for a clear distinction between the roles of the KRA’s board chairman, the board itself, and the Commissioner General. Mbadi has pointed out that the principles of corporate governance must be strictly applied in the management of the KRA, akin to any other corporate body.
“There should be a distinction between the role of the chairperson of the board, the board as a whole, and the Commissioner General as the CEO, and the management officers of KRA,” Mbadi stated. His remarks underline the importance of maintaining proper governance structures within the KRA to ensure its effective operation.
Adding to the complications, Mwaura’s position as KRA chairman is under legal scrutiny. A High Court decision recently declared his appointment illegal, citing that he had an active corruption case at the time of his appointment by President William Ruto. This court ruling has cast a shadow over Mwaura’s leadership, leading him to appeal the decision. The Court of Appeal has since suspended the order to remove him from office pending the hearing of his appeal, allowing Mwaura to retain his position, at least temporarily.
The Conflict of Interests
Mwaura has also faced criticism for holding a dual role within the United Democratic Alliance (UDA) as the chairman of the party’s National Elections Board. This has raised concerns about potential conflicts of interest, especially given the political undertones that often accompany high-profile appointments within government bodies like the KRA. The intersection of his political responsibilities and his role at KRA has led to questions about the impartiality and effectiveness of his leadership at the revenue authority.
Mbadi’s Strategic Vision for KRA
As Mbadi steps into his new role at the Treasury, he has signaled a return to policies that have proven successful in the past, particularly concerning the recruitment and training of graduate trainees at the KRA. These trainees, once recruited, undergo both classroom and on-the-job training to ensure they are well-prepared for their roles within the authority. Mbadi’s support for this approach highlights his commitment to building a well-equipped workforce that can effectively manage the complex tasks associated with tax collection and revenue management.
Mbadi’s reforms also extend to the Finance Bill 2024, which was withdrawn by President Ruto following widespread protests. While acknowledging the contentious nature of the bill, Mbadi has expressed his intent to salvage its positive aspects. Among the provisions he seeks to preserve are the deductibility of the housing levy and post-retirement medical contributions, which are designed to alleviate the financial burden on salaried employees. Additionally, Mbadi has proposed restoring tax relief provisions that would allow the Commissioner to manage uncollectable taxes under unavoidable circumstances, although he cautioned that this must be balanced with controls to prevent abuse.
Expanding the Tax Base and Enhancing the Business Environment
Mbadi’s vision for the KRA includes a broader strategy to expand the tax base, ensuring that traditionally hard-to-collect sectors contribute their fair share. This approach aligns with the national tax policy and aims to protect existing businesses from over-taxation. Mbadi’s metaphor of “protecting the goose that lays the golden egg” reflects his understanding of the need to balance tax collection with the support of business growth and sustainability.
Furthermore, Mbadi has committed to improving the ease of doing business in Kenya. He plans to collaborate with various government departments and stakeholders to review data and legislation, thereby creating a more favorable environment for business operations in the country. This initiative is expected to attract more investment, stimulate economic growth, and ultimately increase tax revenues.
Prudent Fiscal Management
A crucial aspect of Mbadi’s approach to fiscal management is his commitment to the prudent use of Article 223 of the Constitution, which governs the use of public funds. Article 223 allows the national government to spend money without prior approval from Parliament in specific circumstances. Mbadi has emphasized the need for checks and balances in the application of this article to ensure balanced budgets and reduced expenditures.
“If we manage our debt and the application of Article 223 of the Constitution, we have better balanced budgets. We may not need to over-tax because we will have reduced the expenditure side of the budget,” Mbadi stated. His focus on fiscal discipline underscores his broader strategy of ensuring that Kenya’s financial resources are managed responsibly, thereby reducing the need for excessive taxation.
As John Mbadi takes the helm at the National Treasury, his reforms and strategic vision are set to significantly impact Kenya’s fiscal policy and economic environment. His emphasis on corporate governance, prudent fiscal management, and the expansion of the tax base reflects a comprehensive approach to addressing the challenges facing the KRA and the broader economy. However, the ongoing legal battles and governance issues surrounding Anthony Mwaura’s leadership at KRA will continue to pose challenges as Mbadi seeks to implement his agenda. The outcome of these efforts will be crucial in shaping the future of Kenya’s revenue collection and fiscal stability.
