Manchester United, one of the most storied football clubs in the world, finds itself in a difficult position early in the 2024-25 season. Erik ten Hag, the Dutch manager who took the helm of the club in 2022, is facing significant pressure after a disappointing string of results. Despite a summer that saw the club back him with new signings and the hopes of building on past progress, Manchester United’s form has not lived up to expectations, leaving many to question whether Ten Hag’s tenure is nearing its end. In particular, discussions have emerged around who could replace him, with a former Old Trafford superstar, Ruud van Nistelrooy, being tipped as a potential successor.
Manchester United’s Underwhelming Start to 2024-25
The 2024-25 season was expected to be a year of progression for Manchester United under Ten Hag. After two seasons of building and refining the squad, the Dutch manager was supposed to push the team towards greater success, both domestically and in Europe. However, the results so far have been disappointing. With only three wins from their first nine games, United has struggled to find consistency. The team’s recent 3-0 loss to Tottenham Hotspur further compounded the growing dissatisfaction among the fanbase, and whispers of unrest in the locker room began to circulate.
The defeat to Spurs highlighted many of the same issues that have plagued United throughout the season—disorganization in defense, lack of creativity in midfield, and a failure to take chances up front. This is not the United team that fans had hoped for, especially considering the investments made in the summer transfer window. As a result, Ten Hag is under immense pressure to turn things around quickly. The upcoming matches against Porto in the Europa League and Aston Villa in the Premier League are now being seen as pivotal moments in his tenure. Failure to achieve positive results in these games could lead to his dismissal.
Criticism of Ten Hag’s Tactics
One of the key criticisms directed at Ten Hag has been his tactical approach. Once heralded for his ability to implement an attractive, possession-based style of play, the Dutchman has struggled to consistently translate that philosophy to Manchester United. Critics, including former United players, have accused him of lacking a clear plan. The team often looks disjointed on the pitch, with players appearing unsure of their roles and responsibilities.
Defensive frailties have been a major concern. United has conceded goals at an alarming rate, and while individual errors have contributed, the overall defensive structure has often looked vulnerable. In midfield, despite the presence of talented players, United has struggled to control games, frequently being overrun by more organized and disciplined opponents. Offensively, the team has been inconsistent, with moments of brilliance overshadowed by long periods of ineffectiveness.
Former United legend Rio Ferdinand, among others, has voiced his concerns about Ten Hag’s inability to establish a clear identity for the team. He has questioned whether the Dutch manager knows how to get the best out of the players at his disposal, suggesting that United’s struggles stem from a lack of coherent direction.
Ruud van Nistelrooy as a Potential Successor
Amid the growing uncertainty surrounding Ten Hag’s future, former Manchester United scout Mick Brown has suggested that Ruud van Nistelrooy could be a viable replacement. Van Nistelrooy, who enjoyed a prolific playing career at Old Trafford, recently returned to the club as an assistant coach. According to Brown, the former striker possesses the qualities needed to lead the team, at least on an interim basis.
Van Nistelrooy’s appointment as a coach marked a homecoming for one of United’s most revered forwards. During his time as a player at the club, Van Nistelrooy scored 150 goals in 219 appearances, establishing himself as one of the best strikers in the world. His predatory instincts in front of goal and his ability to deliver in big moments endeared him to the United faithful.
However, Van Nistelrooy’s managerial experience is still relatively limited. After retiring from playing, he embarked on a coaching career that saw him take various roles, including working with youth teams. His most significant managerial stint came at PSV Eindhoven, one of the top clubs in the Netherlands. During his time at PSV, Van Nistelrooy led the team to 33 wins in 51 games, showcasing his potential as a manager. PSV’s attacking play under his leadership was particularly impressive, with the team regularly scoring goals in bunches.
But while Van Nistelrooy’s attacking philosophy is well-regarded, his teams have also shown defensive vulnerabilities. PSV conceded 60 goals during his tenure, raising questions about whether he can strike the right balance between attack and defense. Managing Manchester United would be a significant step up from PSV, and the demands and scrutiny would be far greater. Nevertheless, his deep connection to the club, both as a player and now as a coach, makes him a sentimental favorite among some sections of the fanbase.
The Case for an Interim Appointment
One of the reasons Van Nistelrooy is being considered as a potential interim manager is the perceived lack of high-profile alternatives available on the market. Finding the right candidate to lead a club of Manchester United’s stature is no easy task, and many of the top managers in world football are currently employed or may be unwilling to take on the challenge at this moment.
Mick Brown, who was instrumental in bringing Van Nistelrooy to United as a player, believes that giving him the job on an interim basis could be a smart move. If Van Nistelrooy performs well, he could be offered the position on a permanent basis. This approach would give the club time to assess his capabilities without committing to a long-term appointment prematurely.
Interim appointments are not uncommon in football, especially when clubs are in transitional phases. Some of the most successful managerial reigns have started as interim appointments. The theory is that a fresh voice in the dressing room, someone with a deep understanding of the club, can often galvanize the squad and produce improved results in the short term. Van Nistelrooy’s experience at United as a player and his familiarity with the current squad could make him an ideal candidate to step in during a difficult period.
What’s Next for Manchester United?
As things stand, Ten Hag’s future at Manchester United hangs in the balance. The club’s next few fixtures could be crucial in determining whether he retains his job. A strong performance against Porto in the Europa League, followed by a positive result against Aston Villa in the Premier League, could buy him more time to turn things around. However, another string of poor results could see the club’s hierarchy make the decision to part ways with him.
For Manchester United, the stakes are high. The club has been in a rebuilding phase for several years, cycling through multiple managers in the post-Sir Alex Ferguson era, and is desperate to regain its status as a dominant force in both domestic and European football. Firing Ten Hag would represent yet another setback in that process, and the club would need to be careful in selecting his replacement to avoid falling further behind their rivals.
Van Nistelrooy’s name will likely continue to be linked with the job as long as the speculation around Ten Hag’s future persists. Whether or not the former striker is the right man for the job is a matter of debate, but his connection to the club, his experience as a top-level player, and his potential as a coach make him an intriguing option. If Ten Hag is dismissed, Van Nistelrooy’s appointment, even on an interim basis, would be a bold move by the club’s leadership.
In the coming weeks, all eyes will be on Old Trafford as the drama unfolds. Ten Hag’s ability to respond to the pressure and deliver the results United need will determine whether he remains in charge, while Van Nistelrooy will be waiting in the wings, ready to step up if called upon.
