England’s upcoming Test match against Zimbabwe may be a one-off fixture, but it comes with significant implications for the summer ahead particularly the high-stakes India series in June. The squad selection is imminent, and with four rounds of County Championship cricket already in the books, selectors are weighing experience, potential, and form in each department.
At the top of the order, Zak Crawley remains a point of concern. His struggles in New Zealand against Matt Henry highlighted long-standing issues with consistency, and although he boasts a decent average from previous series against India and Australia, a failure to reach three figures since the 2023 Ashes continues to cast doubt. A couple of fifties for Kent suggest improvement, but more is needed. Ben Duckett, meanwhile, is a near-certainty, leaving the No 3 slot in question. Jacob Bethell impressed in New Zealand but is currently tied up with the IPL, and a mid-tournament release appears off the table. This could clear the way for Ollie Pope to return to a top-order role after a solid stint as a stand-in wicketkeeper.
The selectors may also look to introduce Ben McKinney into the environment. The 20-year-old left-hander has made notable impressions for Durham and, despite challenging batting conditions, stood out during a recent low-scoring victory over Worcestershire.
In contrast, the middle order appears well-settled. Joe Root and Harry Brook are back in county action and firmly entrenched in the Test setup. Jamie Smith, now likely to take the gloves permanently, adds further stability after being named one of Wisden’s cricketers of the year. The only point of intrigue could be whether Brook is appointed vice-captain ahead of Pope. The more pressing uncertainty lies with Ben Stokes, who is yet to play this season following hamstring surgery. Although unlikely to feature for Durham beforehand, he remains intent on resuming his all-rounder duties for England, with the Zimbabwe Test potentially his only red-ball outing before the India tour.
In the seam department, injuries continue to restrict options. Chris Woakes has not featured for Warwickshire due to an ankle issue, creating space for Sam Cook to potentially earn a debut. Cook’s stellar first-class record over 300 wickets at under 20—combined with his decision to prioritise the Lions over franchise opportunities, positions him strongly to share the new ball with Gus Atkinson. Josh Tongue, now back from injury and performing well for Nottinghamshire, is another strong candidate. Matthew Potts remains a consistent option, while Sonny Baker, though uncapped, is being monitored closely by England’s management.
Spin remains the most unsettled area. Shoaib Bashir’s record is a mixed bag: 49 wickets in 2024 speak to his promise, but his average and economy rate are less flattering. His slow start to the county season with Glamorgan raises questions about his readiness. Should England reconsider, Liam Dawson presents a more dependable alternative. His performances last year and all-round ability could prove valuable, especially if Woakes is unavailable. Another wildcard is Farhan Ahmed, the 17-year-old off-spinner from Nottinghamshire. He has caught the eye with his energy and skill, though his age and inexperience would make his selection a bold move.
With several places up for grabs, this Zimbabwe Test could serve as both a proving ground for fringe players and a tune-up for key figures. Whether England opt to stick with familiar faces or twist toward the future remains to be seen.
